JCN Home
JCN Home
NCF-JCN Main Page
NCF Home
NCF Home

Back to Article Summary Table of Contents

Complementary & Alternative Therapies
Volume 18, Number 4 Fall 2001

Editorial

Biblical Alternatives

Judith Allen Shelly

Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) continues to make the news. In most health care settings, these therapies are beginning to appear as fairly standard options. However, controversy continues to surround them. Christians seem divided in their acceptance of CAM. A few comments that I’ve heard recently include:

“These therapies allow nurses to manipulate energy to bring harmony and balance, which brings healing. If something has worked for thousands of years, maybe we should try it.”

“Alternative therapies are demonic—Christians should have nothing to do with them.”

“We’ve got to stop being so afraid of new approaches; after all, most of these therapies have been scientifically proven effective now.” On the one hand, it seems that everybody has at least tried a few herbal supplements or relaxation techniques. Reputable health care systems are offering everything from yoga and Reiki to acupuncture. It seems that everybody’s doing it. On the other hand, the nursing literature and popular press increasingly warn about toxic effects of seemingly harmless natural remedies. Scientific studies remain inconclusive, and the proponents of many alternative therapies are becoming more open about their spiritual connections.

How can we faithfully determine whether alternative therapies can be used safely and effectively? The plumb line for the Christian is the Bible, but turning to the Bible for guidance confronts us with some big surprises. Almost all the health care advocated in the Bible consisted of alternative therapies.

When Moses led the nation of Israel out of Egypt, they left behind some of the most advanced medical care in civilization. However, God offered them an alternative health system, saying, “If you will listen carefully to the voice of the Lord your God, and do what is right in his sight, and give heed to his commandments and keep all his statutes, I will not bring upon you any of the diseases that I brought upon the Egyptians; for I am the Lord who heals you” (Ex 15:26). Rather than follow the innately religious health practices of the Egyptians, God instructed the Israelites to set up a program of sanitation, nutrition and healthy relationships (see Leviticus 11—19).

We see other types of alternative therapies in the Old Testament, as well. David used music therapy to comfort Saul (1 Sam 16). Daniel and his friends stayed healthy in captivity by requesting a vegetarian diet instead of the rich food of the Babylonian court (Dan 1). Hezekiah prayed for healing and applied a poultice of figs to his life-threatening abscess (2 Kings 20).

You don’t read much about physicians in the New Testament. Dr. Luke seems to have given up his medical practice to follow Jesus, the Great Physician. In Mark 5, we read about a woman who turned to Jesus as the last alternative, for she had “endured much under many physicians, and had spent all she had; but she was no better, but rather grew worse” (Mk 5:26).

The Bible was never intended to be a medical textbook. It does not provide us with a handy bag of tricks or a set of guaranteed healing techniques. Instead, we find some solid principles for health promotion and caring for the sick.

Principle #1: Follow the laws of nature. The health code in Leviticus provides some fascinating directives. Avoid contaminated food and water. Get enough rest. Use universal precautions—isolate people with contagious diseases; don’t handle food after touching contaminated material until after the incubation period for disease has passed; wash your hands. Keep sexual contact within the boundaries of marriage. Circumcise baby boys. Be careful with body fluids. Take baths. Wash your clothes and bedding after recovering from a contagious disease. Clean the mildew out of your homes. Wash your dishes. And all of this should take place in the context of regular worship and faithful human relationships.

Principle #2: Health is more than the absence of disease. Long before the World Health Organization declared this, the Bible made it clear that true health could be found only in relationship to God and his people. Health and salvation were literally synonymous. Jesus could heal a paralytic by saying, “Your sins are forgiven” (Mt 9:2). Isaiah 53:5 prophesied of the Messiah: “He was wounded for our transgressions . . .and by his bruises we are healed.”

Principle #3: The spiritual connections of a healing technique matter. God warned the Israelites, “Do not turn to mediums or wizards; do not seek them out, to be defiled by them: I am the Lord your God” (Lev 19:31). When Simon the magician sought power to heal for the wrong reasons, the apostles Peter and John censured him publicly (Acts 8:9-13). When the seven sons of Sceva tried to use Jesus’ name as a magic charm to cast out an evil spirit, the demon itself cried out, “Jesus I know, and Paul I know; but who are you?” (Acts 19:13-16). Throughout both the Old and New Testaments, we see the pitfalls of turning to other gods or spirits for healing, knowledge or power. Even if a technique appeared to work, if used for the wrong reasons or in league with the wrong spirits, it eventually brought corruption and spiritual destruction.

Principle #4: Care for the sick. In Luke 10, the story of the Good Samaritan illustrates what faithfulness to God entails. It is embodied in caring for the sick and disenfranchised. Jesus further drove home that point in Matthew 25. Prevention is important, but we will always have the sick among us. We cannot abandon them.

Principle #5: It’s all about faithfulness. God does not guarantee health, wealth, success or even comfort to his people. Jesus healed many people, but he did not heal everyone. Following God’s principles for healthy living may improve our health and prolong our lives, but we will still die. Some of God’s cherished children will die painful deaths at a young age. Others may languish in bodies that will never be whole until they are raised to new life. Life is not fair. But God is just, and his steadfast love endures forever. And so, we wait for a new heaven and a new earth.

In the meantime, as we care for the sick, we can faithfully avail ourselves of all that science, technology and faithful living have to offer. We are free to try alternatives, as long as they do not require us to compromise our good sense or our relationship with God.—JAS

Return to the Fall 2001 Issue

Return to the Journal of Christian Nursing